Have we got an easy and amazingly flavorful cookie recipe for you! Our Rolo cookies have been among our top pinned recipes for the last 3 years straight. When we were challenged by The J.M. Smucker Company to use their new peanut butter powder in a recipe, we knew exactly what we wanted to try: peanut butter Rolo cookies! They are a breeze to make with just 5 ingredients, most of them are probably already in your pantry. Grab the powder at Walmart if not! And they’re fast so you can have warm cookies in your belly in the first 15 minutes of gathering your supplies. Win-win!